Pressure measurement devices: from technical assessment to clinical performance
© Giacomozzi et al; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. 2012
Published: 10 April 2012
Technical assessment of pressure measurement devices (PMDs) should guarantee for their appropriate use in the clinics. The study aims at proving the validity of the assessment methodology ISS proposed , and at quantifying the impact of PMD performance on clinical assessment.
Materials and methods
Three commercial PMDs were first assessed and then compared during barefoot walking: PMDa and PMDb - resistive technology, 1sens/cm2 – were assessed on-site, while PMDc – capacitive technology, 4sens/cm2 - was tested on-the-bench and on-site . The PMDs were aligned on the floor to capture successive at-regimen steps of the left foot of one trained volunteer; 10 complete steps were acquired in both directions for each PMD; data were temporally normalised and averaged; main kinetic parameters were extracted.
Results from the on-the-bench and on-site assessment, and with respect to some clinically relevant parameters.
PMD under test
ISS Full technical assessment
ISS On-site partial assessment
“gait” assessment: Peak pressure (kPa)
“gait” assessment: Mean pressure (kPa))
“gait” assessment: Integral (kPa*s)
error >10% at 250kPa
error < 5% at 250kPa
accuracy error < 5% up to 1200kPa
error < 5% at 250kPa
To conclude: i) on-site assessment up to 250kPa proved to be necessary but not sufficient to guarantee for a good PMD performance during gait; ii) a thorough on-the-bench assessment is effective and recommended; iii) use of PMDb data might be misleading in research and risky in the clinics. The study is going on with the comparison among other commercial PMDs and under a wide range of testing conditions.
- Giacomozzi C: Hardware performance assessment recommendations and tools for baropodometric sensor systems. Ann Ist Super Sanita. 2010, 46: 158-167.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Giacomozzi C: Potentialities and criticalities of Plantar Pressure Measurements in the Study of Foot Biomechanics: Devices, Methodologies and Applications. Biomechanics in Applications. Edited by: Vaclav Klika. 2011, Intech, 249-274. 1Google Scholar
This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.